Fenoglio was born and raised in Denver, Colorado. He graduated from Loyola Marymount University with a Bachelor’s in Natural Science and was a pre-med student. He worked as clinical research coordinator at UCLA and CU-Denver med schools. Fenoglio has been published as co-author on an article for research in ophthalmology. He won a Division I National Championship with Belmont Shore in 2012 and currently plays for Glendale Raptors.